A little earlier this year
a well-known and respected HRD commented that consultants and contractors do
not have the same “skin in the game” as permanent employees and hence do not
put in as much effort as their established colleagues. Although I think I understand
the logic behind his statement, and perhaps I am just lucky, my experience of self-employed
individuals during the past year has been the exact opposite. Without exception,
the itinerant and contract members of the team have put in as much thought and effort
as their permanently employed co-workers. Indeed, without their help we would not have
achieved significant, desired and beneficial change across the organisation
where I work.
Last week the Independent
published an article
entitled “Is this the death of the traditional employee?” It highlighted some significant
changes that have occurred within the UK since 2010, one striking fact is that according to data released and celebrated by the coalition government, 2/5 of all new jobs have arisen
as a result of a significant growth in self-employed workers. 15% of the UK
workforce (circa 4.5 million people) are now freelance workers. The article
goes on to ponder whether these people have been forced into self-employment
(perhaps as an alternative to retirement, having been made redundant following
the economic collapse in 2008, or because of a loss of income support but still
needing to provide for themselves and perhaps a family). Similar points about the rise in the
self-employed sector are made by Barrie Hopson, the co-author, with Katie Ledger, of “And
What Do You Do?: 10 Steps to Creating a Portfolio Career”, on his blog.
Many hats are required for a successful portfolio career |
I am aware of the issues
for many people on zero-hour contracts (as indeed are many more of us, now that
Ed Miliband is planning to use it as his calling card to persuade
the Scots to remain united with England and Wales).
A better blogger than I,
Rick, who writes Flip Chart
Fairy Tales, has been raising the matter of self-employment and the poverty
trap for over a year now – if you want data on the subject read his recent post
on the self-employed
– the nouveau pauvre. I don’t in anyway wish to seem to be supporting the
increasing divide between the affluent and the poor. It is a matter of concern that the median
self-employed annual salary is only £12,000 per annum. The Independent’s piece
questioned whether, as the employment market picks-up, these people will seek
permanent employment. Perhaps the
recruitment firms, or the websites such as LinkedIn, Monster and Jobsite are
best placed to answer that, as they will see the number of job seekers in
relation to opportunities. However, in my experience, the people who are
self-employed and currently working with me (and who admittedly are not on
incomes of £12,000) have no desire to resume employment with a single business.
Rich/Poor Divide King George V driving to Epsom Derby, 1920 with a beggar running beside his carriage |
I like the fact that I can
bring in particular expertise, such as an artist and corporate observer or a great coach and L&D expert,
or a truly smart OD specialist, as and
when I need them, but that I don’t have talented individuals, on my payroll but
not using their specialist skills, when an internal requirement is not there. Talking
with the freelancers I work with, they love the variety of multiple challenges that
their choice of career provides and they find the diversity of projects and
organisations enjoyable. I learn from them and they gain skills from doing
stuff for my organisation. We all have fun and it is rewarding. I am fussy and
believe in working with people I like and respect and whom I know will do
things better than I could. When I returned to work following maternity leave I
only did so after I had hired a nanny who was significantly better at looking
after children than I was. I apply a similar approach to hiring self-employed
specialists.
I am probably the biggest
winner from the arrangement. In a fortnight’s time I am co-facilitating an
industry leading Leadership Development programme in conjunction with the Professional
Services team at Judge Business School of Cambridge University. In addition to the academics, I have brought
together a number of experts – how lucky am I to be able to assemble a dream
team with complimentary skills? Doing things like this in real life beats any
fantasy football game and I learn from and thrive on the diversity of thinking
and approach.
Super heroes - a dream team |
In some ways, I am a good
example of a portfolio careerist.
However, I started enjoying the benefits of variety long before the term
came into common parlance. The author Erin
Albert who wrote “Plan
C: The Full-Time Employee and Part-Time Entrepreneur” says that individuals
who are trying to decide whether they should stick to working for a sole
employer or to become a freelance entrepreneur should look at the patterns of
their earlier life and what they enjoy/have been successful at doing,
especially when at college or university.
I deliberately immersed myself in a broad gamut of areas when a student,
from acting, debating, rowing, painting, cooking, rugby, academic studies, running a fly fishing school, belonging
to societies, organising balls and charity events, socialising, holding down a
job and I was vice chair of the JCR and president of the Law society, as well
as being captain of the first boat for my college. I have always been fond of
personal freedom and variety it brings.
Free Bird by Lynyrd Skynrd
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np0solnL1XY&feature=kp
Much of the secret of
success is being able to understand yourself and to appreciate what you enjoy
and are good at. As well as capability
and desire, you need a degree of self-discipline and focus and possess the skills of a juggler, to hold down multiple roles.
Marc Chagall, The Juggler (1943) |
If you are unsure as to the kind of environment that suits you best and what you should look for from your work environment, this simple quiz might aid your thinking.
In my career, I have been so
fortunate to date, in that I have been able to cross successfully between
different roles and sectors. I am a lawyer who has worked as a derivatives
dealer within the financial markets, before deciding that I find people more
interesting than numbers or contracts (although I can do both). I have worked
in corporate psychology and founded and lead successful businesses, before
moving into HR. Everything I have done has added to my knowledge and skills and
I bring bits together to help me solve problems every day (both at work and in
my broader life). My Twitter self-description of being a “creative connector”
applies to how I work, as well as to the opportunities I am able to provide by
connecting people I know.
Variety is the spice of life Spices in the market in Marrakech, Morocco |
How fortunate I am. I
thank you for being the people I interact with and with whom I have done and I
am able to do interesting and varied things. If I can help you or if you need
someone to bounce ideas off, I would be delighted to hear from you.
I'm Lucky - Live performance by Joan Armatrading
The "skin in the game" argument I find problematical. You have to do something pretty awful as an employee to lose your job, whereas as a self employed consultant, you are constantly on call for your actions and your future is more or less at the whim of your client. Admittedly you can mitigate this by having more than one client etc. I treat every assignment as if it is the first time I've gained a piece of work and would argue that this keeps me fresher than when I knew the wage would appear whatever happened.
ReplyDelete